Determinism vs. Possibilism
Introduction:
No exact answer to this question has yet been found – to what extent do the natural elements of the world affect humans. In modern times, a continuous study of human relations with nature has begun. At present, the view of geographers has changed. The geographers has now human-centered. As a result, the relationship of nature with human beings & human with nature beings, is being studied in a systematic way. The opinion of geographers like Carl Ritter (1779-1859), Alexander Von Humboldt (1761-1859), Hackel, Bukle, Edmond Demolines, F. Ratzel, W.M. Davis, Huntington etc. geographers particularly important in this regard. And of these concepts, two important concepts are:
i. Determinism
ii. Possibilism
:Concept of Determinism in Geography:
According to Determinism, the history, culture, life style & stage of development of a social group or nation are exclusively governed by the physical factors of environment.
Supporter:
The natural environment controls human life. This concept is presented by major geographers of the present century. Namely,
i. Ellen Churchill Semple
ii. Elseworth huntington
iii. Friedrich Ratzel
Example:
Drought, floods, earthquakes, tsunamis etc. natural things are influencing people & nature controls human vision & decision-making process.
Keynotes of Determinism:
i. The determinists generally consider man as a passive agent.
ii. Nature has dominated man.
iii. Nature has controlled human activity & nature has influenced the personal & economic life of people.
iv. Human actions are controlled by nature’s chosen constraints.
v. Differences in human behavior are observed for differences in the natural environment.
vi. Nature acts as determinant of human activities & development of societies.
Development of Determinism:
Age/Era/
Time
|
Ancient Age (1200 B.C. – 500 A.D.)
|
Middle Age (500 – 1100 A.D.)
|
The Renaissance Age (1400 – 1600)
|
Eighteenth Century
|
Nineteenth Century
|
Darwin Phase
|
Twentieth Century
|
Concept
|
Teleologica-l Concept
|
Teleologica-l Concept
|
Teleologica-l Concept
|
Teleologica-l Concept
|
Geographi-c Determinis-m
|
Scientific -Explanation
|
Environmental Determinism
|
Climatic Determinism
| |||||||
Politics & Determinism
| |||||||
Physiological Determinism
| |||||||
Geographers
|
Herodotus, Hippocrates, Eratosthenes, Strabo, Ptolemy
|
Al-Masudi, Al-Idrisi, Al-Battani, Ibn-Hawqul
|
Cluverius, N. Carpenter, Jean Bodin, Montesquieu
|
Immanuel Kant, stocking
|
Carl Ritter, Humboldt
|
Darwin, Ratzel, Haeckel, Spencer
|
Huntington, C. Semple, Mackinder, P. Geddes
|
Reason for the Fall of Determinism:
i. Lack of Flexibility: The ultimate cause of this decline is the extreme & rigid form of the concept of determinism.
ii. Overriding Human Role: Supporter of the humanitarian view criticize determinism, for the concept of determinism does not give the least importance to the human role on earth.
iii. Technology Improvements: The developments of human technology encourages people to influence nature & the concept of determinism is criticized.
iv. Theoretical Weaknesses: The theoretical side of the determinism is quick weak.
v. Impact of World War II: World War II brings a devastating catastrophe to civilization & society around the world. Determinism concept gradually lost its popularity as it re-imagined the role of people in changing society & civilization.
:Concept of Possibilism in Geography:
According to Concept of Possibilism, the natural environment of each region presents some possibilities to the people of the region. Among these possibilities, people choose the one that best fits their culture.
Supporter:
There are two notable proponents of this idea of Possibilism-
i. Vidal de la Blache
ii. Lucien Febvre
Example:
People build canals in extreme drought areas to make crop production useful.
Keynotes of Possibilism:
The issues that have been emphasized in the concept of Possibilism are:
i. The environment is controlling people, on the contrary, human are also changing their own environment.
ii. Nature is considered to be the adviser, man is free to select among these advices.
iii. Man is considered to be active in selecting the possibilities offered by nature.
iv. Nature offers opportunities & man selects best among them according to his need, technology, tradition, belief & culture.
Development of Possibilism:
Era/Time/Age
|
Pre-19th Century
|
19th Century
|
20th Century
| |
Concept
|
Crypto-possibilistic Concept
|
Dominance of Man over Nature
|
Possibilism
|
Cultural Landscape & Human Biology
|
Geographers
|
Plato, Montesquieu, Comte de Buffon, Immanuel Kant
|
Alfred Kirchhoff, Paul Vidal de la Blache
|
Lucien Febvre, Jean Brunhes
|
Alfred Hettner, Marton I. Newbigin
|
Reason for the Concept of Possibilism is Popularity:
i. Emphasis on People: The first geography of the Possibilism aspect is to acknowledge the human role. This doctrine quickly became acceptable because of the two-dimensional explanation of human nature.
ii. Humanitarian View: According to Determinism, people are trivial. Many geographers does not accept this concept. Possibilism is becoming increasing popular for more humanitarians this concept.
iii. New Technology Emergence: Improving technology encourages people to interfere with nature. Based on these conditions, it became easier to broaden the doctrine of Possibilism.
iv. Impact of World War I: The unfortunate geographical manifestation of the military power of the people of the World War I had begun to re-think geographically. In fact, the role of World War I is of paramount importance as a prime example of human power & the nature of change.
:Dichotomy/Distinguish Between Determinism & Possibilism:
Subjects
|
Determinism
|
Possibilism
|
i. Definition
|
The history, culture, life style & stage of development of a social group or nation are exclusively governed by the physical factors of environment, is called determinism.
|
The natural environment of each region presents some possibilities to the people of the region. Among these possibilities, people choose the one that best fits their culture, is called possibilism.
|
ii. Principles
|
Nature controls & dominates over life style, activities, occupation, culture, social & economic development of a society & physical as well as psychological structure of human being.
|
Nature offers opportunities & man selects best among them according to his need, technology, tradition, belief & culture.
|
iii. Role of Nature
|
Nature acts as determinant of human activities & development of societies.
|
Nature is considered to be the adviser, man is free to select among these advices.
|
iv. Role of Man
|
Man is considered to be passive & is controlled by nature.
|
Man is considered to be active in selecting the possibilities offered by nature.
|
v. Time
|
In post-Darwinism phase up to 1930s, determinism developed as a well-established Paradigm.
|
In the first decades of 20th century possibilism become popular.
|
vi. School of Geographers
|
German & American School of Geography contributed mainly for development of determinism.
|
French School of Geography led by Vidal de la Blache contributed for possibilism ( School of Possibilism).
|
vii. Scientific Basis
|
Determinism has a firm scientific base supported by Darwinism.
|
Scholars are doubtful on the scientific base of possibilism.
|
viii. Supporter
|
Ellen Churchill Semple
Elseworth huntington
Friedrich Ratzel
|
Vidal de la Blache
Lucien Febvre
|
ix. Control of Build Culture
|
The environment forces people to build a culture.
|
The environment is not the first architect of human culture.
|
x. Field of Importance
|
More importance has been placed on nature then on humans.
|
More importance has been placed on people then on nature.
|
Conclusion:
By dividing the ideas of Determinism & Possibilism, we can conclude that an idea is not entirely acceptable. This difference proves that the social, culture & environment has evolved mainly though the reciprocal relationship of human & nature.
---------------------------------
Comments
Post a Comment